Skip to content

The Clash: Overrated

When the Clash were first emerging from Malcolm Mclaren’s “Sex” boutique in Chelsea, Vivienne Westwood’s aide de camp Bernie Rhodes would regale listeners by spinning his favorite song: “Theme From The Monkees” and in a thunderclap of inspiration what the Clash were became clear: not revolution, but bubblegum rock. Bernie was raised in orphanages and on the streets of London, he was what punk claimed to be(while actually a variant on art rock), the revenge of the guttersnipe. Bernie added hooks to teeny bop riots. It’s Malcolm’s fault. Malcolm who forced Bernie’s hand by refusing to allow him to co-manage the Sex Pistols.

It was Bernie who arranged Johnny Rotten’s audition at Sex, it was Bernie who introduced Mick Jones and Paul Simonon to Joe Strummer, it was Bernie  who had the vision of a punk rock so captivatingly great sounding it could ride past the Pistols all the way to the USA.

In 1977, the Clash released their eponymous debut in the UK, in 1979, tailing after Give Em Enough Rope, they released the US version. In 1977 the Clash were second on the line-up for the terrifying Anarchy In The UK Tour, and, in January 1980 (winter is a celebrated dumping ground for no chance album), released London Calling.

The Clash were, in their own way, as manufactured as the Monkees, taking off the zips and leather, they were, in fact, a positioned to take on the Pistols in Punk Rock, less The Couturier Situationists and more dub plus Tommy Boyce and Bobby Hart, – stick like glue, fast, loud pop glam. In 1977, Joe Strummer (nee: John Mellor)  was twenty-five years old (Johnny Rotten was 22), what had this to do with teenagers who’d never get a job? And what do we care?

I don’t care… people fool  themselves in anyway they wish, and, like the Monkees, the Clash  began to believe in themselves, and lead by Joe Strummer, they made a serious attempt to change  not the world, but the relationship between artist and audience. It wasn’t true, but they made a lot of kids going nowhere believe they too could do it as well, they could be the Clash. The band danced on the dividing line between us and them and them and them.

That first album was the future of pop in 1977, it didn’t last but it was sure one shiny moment, and unlike the pub and prog of the early 70s, and just like the Pistols, it was a singles art form first and it took on the UK single by single. In a rush, they went “White Riot,” “Remote Control,” “Complete Control,” “Clash City Rockers,”(White Man) In Hammersmith Palais”… a great string of hits, not the Supremes sure, but pretty damn impressive and then… “Tommy Gun” and just like that, they stopped mattering. By 1979, punk as art as teen revolution was dead and it became something else again, and what it became wasn’t that important and that is where the Clash’s inauthenticity bit them hard. Bernie made em into international pop stars and Strummer and Jones lost the secret ingredient, and while they weren’t bad, they weren’t what people wanted them to be.

Let’s look at the albums:

The Clash (UK) (1977)  – A+

Give ‘Em Enough Rope  (1978) – B-

The Clash (US) (1979) – A+

London Calling (1979) – B

Sandinista (1980) – A

Combat Rock (1982) – C+

Cut The Crap (1985) – C-

In 1976. the majority of teenagers in the UK would never have a job, Strummer and Jones captured the socialist paradise not postponed, in a manufactured, media mirrored dreamscape of nihilism…

The Clash (1977) – England  Paradise Derailed

Give Em Enough Rope (1978)  – European Paradise Derailed

London Calling (1979) – North American  Paradise Derailed

Sandinista (1980) – South American Paradise Derailed

Combar Rock (1982) – Hot 100 Paradise Derailed

Cut The Crap (1985) – The Clash Paradise Derailed

To remain in 1977, the kick against the Clash -authentic or fakes, political situationists and liars or the voice of the people, whatever they were, they were great. And if Bernie Rhodes job was to get em signed to a major, of course it was. Plus, hell, at least they had a vision of bubblegum Bobby Fuller rock and roll as firebomb and everything they did, headed by their Monkees tribute, “Clash City Rockers,” resonated with their audience. In retrospect, the Pistols “no future in England dreaming” was a deeper, less prosaic version than the Clash’s new religion-television axis. Those songs, that first and second batch, were very important while being entirely built for a reason. Cynicism was the least of the Clash’s problems…

The difference between 1978 and 1977 is that Strummer and Jones lost some of their mojo, sure “Stay Free” is one of Mick’s greatest moments, “Guns On The Roof” (about when they got arrested for shooting pigeons) is a disgrace as a song and as a point of view, “All The Young Punks (New Boots And Contracts)” is the height of hypocrisy, “Tommy Gunn” is second tier 1977, “Safe European Home” is great… and as a single-minded piece of agitprop it doesn’t work. Preferring Give ‘Em Enough Rope to The Clash is like preferring yoghurt to ice-cream. The only band that mattered had failed to maintain it over even two albums.

Meanwhile… you can take the streets out of the rock star but you can’t make Joe Strummer into John Lennon… the Clash, always vastly bigger in the States than the irascible Sex Pistols, in January 1980, they released London Calling and cemented their position as resident good guys by selling the double at the price of a single… The band’s most beloved album was also their trickiest, how do they keep true to their, initially feigned, political radicalism and still be the biggest band in the world?

In 1980, Strummer and band were being bombarded with information, “We have friends and they tell us stuff” is how Paul put it to me (the only band that natters). In 1982, they responded with the clearly received but no less important take on South America via World music Sandinista! One of my favorite albums (not best) by anyone, “The Magnificent Seven” is a signpost they blew up with Combat Rock, and destroyed with Cut The Crap, while Joe couldn’t figure out who to lash out at next. The Clash didn’t explode, they were fired by Joe. He jumped off the deep end and it would take him years to get back on track, though once he did it lead him to the Saint Joe of legend… the Saint Joe after the Clash.

The Clash’s problem was they couldn’t maintain the early genius and they were forced into being stuck between rock stardom and socialist stalwarts, the two were a tough mesh -Pete Seeger managed it, John Lennon less so. But once he left The Clash and steadied himself Joe did it, he became the man he wanted to be.

However, this is about the Clash being overrated.

The band’s position is one of the biggest rock bands of all times, just a little below the Stones and the Who but certain admired more than the Faces, the Sex Pistols, any of those 80s hardcore bands, or 90s Britrockers. Bigger than Nirvana.

But the catalog just doesn’t justify it.

There is an early period and a late period but no real mid-period, the politics while not inaccurate are obvious, they don’t live up to their self-regard (read Lester Bang’s Creem interview), and if the answer is “no one else has ever tried”, so what? And what they are unwilling to do themselves, they have Bernie dirty his hands, so even they didn’t really try. More than a pose, it was also only a pose. .

The Clash have three huge problems as far as an accurate assessment of their career is concerned:

1 – The music nosedives

2 – The politics (both personal and social) sputters to a halt.

3 – And they are still and always manufactured in a manner that, say, Radiohead and Pink Floyd were not.

Sure, we love them but we lie about them. The Clash are overrated.



1 Comment

  1. Mark Boyle on February 21, 2020 at 1:20 pm

    Aside from yes it is true The Clash were overrated, so much of what you said is nothing but part of The Clash members own mythology. (Rhodes had nothing to do with the Sex Pistols full stop: it was Jones and Cook who suggested Johnny Rotten, not Rhodes), the Clash were total hype from beginning to end, wearing gear made for them by Jasper and Sebastian Conran.

    They even paid the Socialist Workers Party (a violent Trotskyite group run along network marketing lines which has made many suspect their purpose is to discredit socialism whilst compensating its leadership with very well paid jobs for life) money to trash competitors gigs and to ensure Tony Parsons and Julie Burchill of the New Musical Express (both SWP members) wrote over the top glowing reviews.

    They were nowhere near “the biggest band in the world”. They were a minor punk act in the UK – miles behind the Pistols, Boomtown Rats, Stranglers, Sham 69 and Siouxsie and The Banshees in terms of record sales (and the second band was on the tiny Ensign label, not one of the big three like CBS as The Clash were), their biggest hit whilst together being London Calling, which stalled at No. 12. By way of contrast, five years later, the Toy Dolls, who hadn’t even been formed when the latter single came out, got to No.4 in the same mainstream UK charts in the highly congested Christmas week with “Nellie The Elephant/Fisticuffs In Frederick Street”).

    Apart from one top ten single in the US (Rock The Casbah) and two in France (London Calling and Should I Stay Or Should I Go) during their time together, the fact is their stuff never sold. It’s only been since the 1990s their back catalogue has acquired gold/silver, etc discs, partly from people going over from vinyl to CD but mainly because the criteria for awarding these discs has been slashed over the years due to the decline in the music market.

    In 1979, you had to sell a million units to get a platinum album disc and two million for a single. But in the late 80s these were halved, and bands began to receive retrospective gold and platinum discs as marketing ploys – hence the proliferation of discs awarded to the Clash in the 1990s.

    Indeed, their biggest hit was their solitary UK No.1 when “Should I Stay Or Should I Go?” got to No.1 nine years after its original release on the back of it being used in an advert for denims by a firm criticised for Third World exploitation factories – so much for their politics! One result of this was the Genesis single “I Can’t Dance” lampooning the advert The Clash had got their posthumous big hit from.

    Their refusal to play “Top Of The Pops” was a carbon copy of what the prog bands did – Genesis under Peter Gabriel in particular earned notoriety by refusing to go on when “I Know What I Like” became a hit. It continued when Gabriel left Genesis and Robin Nash (the TOTP producer) deliberately played “Solsbury Hill” as the outtro for the credits during its chart run to annoy him. Nash did the same with the Sex Pistols whom he was never allowed to bring into the studios due to a diktat from Broadcasting House management. In the case of The Clash, he’d have their songs done to Pans People or Legs & Co dancing, knowing that would make them look naff.

Leave a Comment


Support Let Me Help Inc by shopping at

ROCKSTAR REVIEW: Dr. Mobi -Entertainment Visionary

By Meredith Grant | January 20, 2022 |

Mubasher Fazal lovingly known as Dr. Mobi is a superstar of many talents.

“Frank Sinatra’s Greatest Hits, Vol. 2” Reviewed

By Iman Lababedi | January 20, 2022 |

took another iteration away from the hippies before young America caught up with him again

Brushes With Greatness: SohoJohnny Meets Randy Edelman

By Iman Lababedi | January 20, 2022 |

the legendary movie composer and sometimes popster

Rap Lyrics As Criminal Evidence In Trials?

By Alyson Camus | January 20, 2022 |

Several prominent rappers have signed a letter

ROCK STAR REVIEW: Tony Moore “Never Gonna Say Goodbye”

By Eileen Shapiro | January 19, 2022 |

.“Never Gonna Say Goodbye” is as touching as brushing against the wings of an Angel.

US Top 10 Singles Tracking 1-7-21 – 1-13-22

By Iman Lababedi | January 19, 2022 |

sure we are well sick of “Easy On Me”

Brief Encounters: New Long Player Releases 1-14-22 – 1-20-22 Reviewed

By Iman Lababedi | January 19, 2022 |

finest sustained moments

Live Nation Announces: “When We Were Young”

By Alyson Camus | January 19, 2022 |

looks like a crazy intense day

US Top 10 Albums Tracking 1-7-22 – 1-13-22

By Iman Lababedi | January 18, 2022 |

Gunna: 150,300, Abel: 148,000: it amounts to a statistical error

Confirmed: There Was Blood Everywhere In The House Where Elliott Smith Was Stabbed

By Alyson Camus | January 18, 2022 |

the police owe us an explanation.

Scroll To Top